LASER Focus Advances Knowledge of How Gulf of Mexico Water Moves

CARTHE drifter trajectories in the Gulf of Mexico superimposed on AVISO surface currents. Red squares mark drifters positions on 9 March 2016 and the tails are 14 days long. (Credit: Edward Ryan and Tamay Ozgokmen from the University of Miami)

(Click to enlarge) CARTHE drifter trajectories in the Gulf of Mexico superimposed on AVISO surface currents. Red squares mark drifters positions on 9 March 2016 and the tails are 14 days long. (Credit: Edward Ryan and Tamay Ozgokmen from the University of Miami)

 

L: A 3-D printer created small-scale drifter prototypes (photo: Novelli). Top right: Cedric Guigand and Guillaume Novelli hold the 1st production-grade assembled drifter after they and Charles Cousin conducted two years of R&D (photo: Ozgokmen). Bottom right: Full and half-scale drifters side by side. The surface ring provides buoyancy; its open design and narrow neck prevent wind from lifting or tilting the drifter. (Photo: Novelli)

(Click to enlarge) L: A 3-D printer created small-scale drifter prototypes (photo: Novelli). Top right: Cedric Guigand and Guillaume Novelli hold the 1st production-grade assembled drifter after they and Charles Cousin conducted two years of R&D (photo: Ozgokmen). Bottom right: Full and half-scale drifters side by side. The surface ring provides buoyancy; its open design and narrow neck prevent wind from lifting or tilting the drifter. (Photo: Novelli)

The team conducted thousands of drifter tests and experiments in the SUSTAIN wind-wave tank. L: Cedric Guigand tests a drifter. Top Right: The tank’s wind-generating machine. The difficult and creative work resulted in significantly improved drifters with a patent application. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

(Click to enlarge) The team conducted thousands of drifter tests and experiments in the SUSTAIN wind-wave tank. L: Cedric Guigand tests a drifter. Top Right: The tank’s wind-generating machine. The difficult and creative work resulted in significantly improved drifters with a patent application. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

 

The aerostat team conducts field tests to check the winch, lines, and the camera platform. Dan Carlson led the development of the aerostat and its imaging platform that carried a 50 mega-pixel Canon DSLR camera. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

(Click to enlarge) The aerostat team conducts field tests to check the winch, lines, and the camera platform. Dan Carlson led the development of the aerostat and its imaging platform that carried a 50 mega-pixel Canon DSLR camera. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

 

Top Left: Forrest Glenn Middle School students paint drift cards. Bottom Left:  West Miami Middle School students display their painted drift cards.  R: Test drift cards in Biscayne Bay. (Photos by CARTHE)

(Click to enlarge) Top Left: Forrest Glenn Middle School students paint drift cards. Bottom Left: West Miami Middle School students display their painted drift cards. R: Test drift cards in Biscayne Bay. (Photos by CARTHE)

 

L: Crews load the towed CTD on the Walton Smith. Top Right: Eric D’Asaro (L) helps situate one of the solar-and-wave-powered gliders which travels 14 days at 1 m/s. Bottom Right: Brian Haus and team set up the X-Band Radar tower that takes 1 m resolution wave measurements in a 3 km radius. (Photos: D’Asaro and Ozgokmen)

(Click to enlarge) L: Crews load the towed CTD on the Walton Smith. Top Right: Eric D’Asaro (L) helps situate one of the solar-and-wave-powered gliders which travels 14 days at 1 m/s. Bottom Right: Brian Haus and team set up the X-Band Radar tower that takes 1 m resolution wave measurements in a 3 km radius. (Photos: D’Asaro and Ozgokmen)

 

L: Autonomous 3D Lagrangian floats, ready for vessel loading, measure vertical velocities in the turbulent mixed layer (photo: Ozgokmen). R:  Surface drifters in a container ready to launch. (Photo: Novelli)

(Click to enlarge) L: Autonomous 3D Lagrangian floats, ready for vessel loading, measure vertical velocities in the turbulent mixed layer (photo: Ozgokmen). R: Surface drifters in a container ready to launch. (Photo: Novelli)

 

L: The Masco VIII tows the aerostat as it images drift cards (credit Dan Carlson). Top right: The crew rescues the aerostat from being dislodged by wind (provided by CARTHE).  Bottom right: Crews deploy drifters in rough seas across from the Walton Smith. (Photo: Novelli)

(Click to enlarge) L: The Masco VIII tows the aerostat as it images drift cards (credit Dan Carlson). Top right: The crew rescues the aerostat from being dislodged by wind (provided by CARTHE). Bottom right: Crews deploy drifters in rough seas across from the Walton Smith. (Photo: Novelli)

 

Top left: Jeroen Molemaker prepares the UCLA plane. Bottom left: Aerial view of LASER operations. R: Aerial surveys found strong frontal features. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

(Click to enlarge) Top left: Jeroen Molemaker prepares the UCLA plane. Bottom left: Aerial view of LASER operations. R: Aerial surveys found strong frontal features. (Photos: Ozgokmen)

 

Some of the LASER operational team, L to R:  Ming Shao, Angelique C. Haza, Karthrine Howe, Hanjing Dai, Laurent Grare, Alexander Soloviev, Guillaume Novelli, Tamay Ozgokmen, Eric D’Asaro, Cedric Guigand, Maristella Berta, John Kluge, Sharon Chinchilla, Nathan Laxague, Andrey Shcherbina, Chris MacKay, and Michael Ohmart. (Photo provided by CARTHE)

(Click to enlarge) Some of the LASER operational team, L to R: Ming Shao, Angelique C. Haza, Karthrine Howe, Hanjing Dai, Laurent Grare, Alexander Soloviev, Guillaume Novelli, Tamay Ozgokmen, Eric D’Asaro, Cedric Guigand, Maristella Berta, John Kluge, Sharon Chinchilla, Nathan Laxague, Andrey Shcherbina, Chris MacKay, and Michael Ohmart. (Photo provided by CARTHE)

 

The RV Walton Smith steaming to the Desoto Canyon in the Gulf of Mexico. (Photo: Novelli)

(Click to enlarge) The RV Walton Smith steaming to the Desoto Canyon in the Gulf of Mexico. (Photo: Novelli)

 

CARTHE conducts unprecedented experiment to improve oil fate models

Predictions for decisions – our world relies on them, from daily weather to annual financial forecasts. Predictions, though, are only as good as the information that goes into making them. And those predictions carry even more weight when they involve human safety in situations like storm tracking, search and rescue, and pollution monitoring.

The Gulf Coast experienced such a situation during the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Answers to where was the oil going, how much was involved, and when would it arrive would influence many decisions. Responders used the best available resources for decision-making, but the blowout’s magnitude and depth was a first for the Gulf and the need for improved transport modeling became apparent.

The CARTHE group, 75 researchers and staff representing 26 institutions, recently carried out a month-long experiment in the Gulf of Mexico named the LAgrangian Submesoscale ExpeRiment or LASER. Their goal: make quantum leaps in improved ocean transport predictions. Years of planning, designing, and testing preceded this highly-orchestrated event that went beyond previous scales and scope.

Using two research vessels, three planes, and cutting-edge technology, the LASER team acquired troves of ocean data from hundreds of survey miles; 1,000 biodegradable drifters; 8,000 high-resolution photos; 10,000 biodegradable drift cards; and 500,000 infrared images. This monumental effort is already paying off big dividends with nearly ten million data transmissions to date, providing information that prediction models can use now.

“We produced a wonderful dataset.  I don’t think anything quite like this has been done before.” Professor Eric D’Asaro, Applied Physics Laboratory and School of Oceanography, University of Washington and LASER’s Scientific Lead and Chief Scientist on MV Walton Smith

SOME BACKGROUND

The theories driving CARTHE research are that the accurate prediction of an oil spill’s first mile of transport is critical for accurately predicting its last mile and that surface transport is strongly influenced by what’s happening just below the sea surface and where air and water meet.

CARTHE’s first experiment, the Grand LAgrangian Deployment or GLAD, was the largest oceanic surface drifter deployment to date and demonstrated the importance of observing surface currents for accurate transport predictions. The 317 GLAD drifters rapidly spread in the first few hours and days, then continued more slowly afterwards. GLAD data improved operational circulation models, but they needed more detailed observations on the physical processes driving surface dispersion.  So LASER picked up where GLAD left off, collecting high-resolution data that measures complex upper-ocean processes driving the initial quick burst and longer-term dispersion. LASER data will complement the GLAD data and provide better understanding about seasonal variability and its influence on water transport.

NOVEL TACTICS AND TECHNOLOGY FOR OCEANOGRAPHIC STUDIES

The LASER team went back to the drawing board to advance ocean transport predictions. They spent more than two years researching and developing a new generation drifter that addressed limitations of the GLAD drifter design. The new drifter had to be biodegradable, light weight, compact, cost efficient, easily produced and assembled, and could float and track currents in high winds and waves.

An operational version emerged after experiments in the SUSTAIN wind-wave tank facility and in nearby Biscayne Bay. These ‘roving detectives’ equipped with satellite trackers can transmit data for several months without leaving behind thousands of plastic skeletons (drifters are 99.9% biodegradable due to their tiny GPS board). Researchers also designed autonomous 3-D Lagrangian floats that measure vertical velocities a few meters below the sea surface. These floats and drifters provide data to advance knowledge about surface and water column transport.

Complementing the drifters were bamboo drift cards, which local middle-school students helped color for visual identification using non-toxic paint.  Researchers used these drift cards to measure dispersion by waves, winds and ocean currents at scales of 1 meter-100 meters and seconds-hours.  The cards thin design (~1 millimeter) allowed researchers to capture the top-most surface velocity needed for oil dispersion studies. Since the cards could not be fitted with tracking devices, the team developed a Ship-Tethered Aerostat Remote Sensing System (STARSS) – a helium-filled balloon carrying a high resolution camera and positioning system – to provide spatial context and real-time observations of drift card dispersion and surface features.

LASER incorporated aircraft surveys, ship measurements, and real-time assimilative models to guide drifter deployments under cloudy conditions and identify quickly-evolving features. Two dual-engine Partanavia p86 planes from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and Scripps Institution of Oceanography operated high-resolution thermal and hyperspectral imagers that geo-rectify images. The NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) provided a high-resolution AirSWOT, an airborne version of a new altimeter sensor to be installed on satellites in 2020. The JPL-CARTHE collaboration provided ground truthing for NASA sensor measurements and additional detailed mapping capability for LASER. 

Shipboard surveys provided fine-scale real-time data on air-sea flux, density, temperature, salinity, velocity, wind, and waves. Instruments included an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler; a Rockland Scientific Profiler; a towed conductivity, temperature, and depth (CTD) system (freeing the crew from making numerous, single-point casts); an X-band wave radar tower; meteorological buoys; and robotic wave gliders.  The University of Miami Coupled Atmosphere-Wave-Ocean Model and the Navy Coastal Ocean model assimilated incoming data. The modelling team made available the resulting high-resolution forecasts of weather, waves, and circulations in real time through a central website to aide LASER deployment decisions.

LASER BY LAND, SEA, AND AIR

“I was excited about LASER, but sobered by the magnitude of what we needed to accomplish.” Eric D’Asaro on transitioning from planning to execution

It took almost three days to load ten tons of equipment on the R/V Walton Smith and U/V Masco VIII.  Teams manned forklifts and loaded containers with drifters, cards, gliders, and the aerostat.  They welded winches, bolted down the wave radar tower, and tested connections for data exchange and communications. Modelers ran forecasts while the Walton Smith sailed from Miami to join the Masco VIII in Key West. Crews battened down the hatches and waited out a storm, then set sail together on January 18 with threatening skies and rough seas as their constant companions for the next month.

Intense storms set the crews’ timing and pace. Everyone braced for demanding work, assembling and staging drifters and communicating constantly as they organized day and night shifts to work during fair weather windows. The UCLA plane generated sea-surface-temperature (SST) maps for the first deployment site where the crews worked speedily as weather deteriorated, deploying 300+ drifters in five hours and surveying the area. Then they headed for safe harbor in Gulfport, MS.

A variety of adjustments had to be made while at sea. The teams identified islands near the mouth of the Mississippi River to wait out storms and quickly return to work. The Masco VIII crew constructed a hammock to keep the aerostat out of water pooling on deck.  The UCLA plane conducted 6+ hours of aerial surveys, identifying frontal features and producing nearly instantaneous maps of the 10km x 10km region where crews deployed drifters, gliders, and drift cards. The Masco VIII team imaged the drift cards with the aerostat for six hours.  The Walton Smith team surveyed a freshwater front’s leading edge, releasing drifters and a glider for continued data gathering.

Crews were on their way to the next site but had to return to island shelter as a forth storm passed. Long hours and rough conditions began taking a toll: equipment malfunctions caused the aerostat to tear, the planes’ imaging equipment needed repairs, the Masco VIII’s internet stopped, and the Walton Smith’s water filtering pump broke requiring strict water rations. But everyone rallied. UCLA, Scripps, and the NASA/JPL aircraft jointly surveyed drifters, final deployment sites, and fronts. Making up lost time, three pilots took shifts on the UCLA plane and conducted a 110-hour around-the-clock mission.

“The aerial observation crew’s determination and the maps they produced injected Red Bull into LASER, giving the team tremendous focus to capture some of our most valuable data.” Professor Tamay Ozgokmen, Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, University of Miami and CARTHE Director

Over a 14-hour period, teams deployed one drifter every six minutes and released drift cards tracking them and a nearby front with the aerostat for nearly seven hours. They deployed gliders, buoys, and took shipboard measurements and imagery of air-sea fluxes, density, and surface and subsurface structures. Again, they scurried for shelter from yet another storm, but their priority work – capturing small-scale ocean processes that had never been measured – was done.

The Masco VIII steamed home to Key West while the Walton Smith crew found and inspected 18 drifters for damage. Aerial observations located 100+ drifters converging near the Deepwater Horizon site, so the Walton Smith crew released the 3D Lagrangian floats to measure vertical velocities there. They also completed a 24-hour moving-vessel-profiler survey and then headed to Miami.  Safely home on February 15, they celebrated their successful month-long field campaign, happy to hear that over four million drifter position transmissions had already been received.

WHAT’S NEXT?

A period of introspection and data analysis follows. LASER’s millions of datapoints and images presents organization challenges and requires automated methods for quality control and analysis. Preliminary evaluation shows that the innovative approach of high-resolution SST and drifter data revealed small scale ocean structures not previously observed. LASER’s wealth of information can be leveraged for years to come as its data is made available in the Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative Information and Data Cooperative (GRIIDC) system.

“LASER pushed the boundaries of ocean observations, furthering our understanding about the processes that govern upper-ocean transport. Lessons learned from LASER will help us do an even better job in the next experiment.” Jeroen Molemaker, University of California at Los Angeles and LASER’s Aerial Observations Chief Scientist

CARTHE’s next experiment, Submesoscale Processes and Lagrangian Analysis on the Shelf or SPLASH, will build upon their previous Surfzone Coastal Oil Pathway Experiment or SCOPE that measured processes influencing the last mile of oil transport. Their subsurface plume research is combining laboratory and numerical modeling to understand how hydrocarbons move through the water column.

Advancing ocean science wasn’t the only thing LASER accomplished – it provided field experience and professional development for graduate students and young scientists, using a bigger-picture interdisciplinary approach to investigate ocean processes.

Scientists will use data from GLAD, SCOPE, LASER, and SPLASH to construct a more complete picture of transport pathways and physical processes near the Deepwater Horizon site and continental shelf regions. This information will assist in reconstructing flows above and below the sea surface, allowing for improved retrospective analysis of spills and transport predictions in future emergencies.  CARTHE’s research has far-reaching applications with new scientific insights that can inform navigation, energy production, climate science, hurricane predictions, search and rescue, and beach safety.

************

This research was made possible in part by a grant from the Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative (GoMRI) to the Consortium for Advanced Research on Transport of Hydrocarbon in the Environment (CARTHE).

 The GoMRI is a 10-year independent research program established to study the effect, and the potential associated impact, of hydrocarbon releases on the environment and public health, as well as to develop improved spill mitigation, oil detection, characterization and remediation technologies.  An independent and academic 20-member Research Board makes the funding and research direction decisions to ensure the intellectual quality, effectiveness and academic independence of the GoMRI research.  All research data, findings and publications will be made publicly available.  The program was established through a $500 million financial commitment from BP. 

© Copyright 2010- 2017 Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative (GoMRI) – All Rights Reserved. Redistribution is encouraged with acknowledgement to the Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative (GoMRI). Please credit images and/or videos as done in each article. Questions? Contact web-content editor Nilde “Maggie” Dannreuther, Northern Gulf Institute, Mississippi State University (maggied@ngi.msstate.edu).